Oct
20
To be, or not to be (part of social media), that is the (big) question:
October 20, 2009 | 5 Comments
There is a buzz around whether to incorporate social media ℠ in your business or marketing strategy. You see comments like ‘it is a fad’, ‘I don’t understand it’, ‘it is expensive’, ‘it is not measurable’ or ‘what is the ROI?’ So I decided to go on a journey to get to the bottom of social media and investigate whether it can be useful in business.
To start with I decided to see if I could find a solid definition of SM. Boy is that hard, there are so many variations and opinions. The one I found most useful was Wikipedia’s page on SM. I like the way it is broken down into different types of channels which make sense to me. Saying that some of these mediums may already be out-dated. I also note they feel that it needs more information and resources, however I found it useful. Here is the list from their example:
Communication
Blogs: Blogger, LiveJournal, Open Diary, TypePad, WordPress, Vox, ExpressionEngine, Xanga
Micro-blogging / Presence applications: Twitter, Plurk, Tumblr, Jaiku, fmylife
Social networking: Bebo, Facebook, LinkedIn, MySpace, Orkut, Skyrock, Hi5, Ning, Elgg
Social network aggregation: NutshellMail, FriendFeed
Events: Upcoming, Eventful, Meetup.com
Collaboration
Wikis: Wikipedia, PBwiki, wetpaint
Social bookmarking (or social tagging)[5]: Delicious, StumbleUpon, Google Reader, CiteULike
Social news: Digg, Mixx, Reddit, NowPublic
Opinion sites: epinions, Yelp
Multimedia
Photo sharing: Flickr, Zooomr, Photobucket, SmugMug, Picasa
Video sharing: YouTube, Vimeo, sevenload
Livecasting: Ustream.tv, Justin.tv, Stickam, Skype
Audio and Music Sharing: imeem, The Hype Machine, Last.fm, ccMixter
Reviews and Opinions
Product Reviews: epinions.com, MouthShut.com
Business Reviews: yelp.com
Community Q&A: Yahoo! Answers, WikiAnswers, Askville, Google Answers
Entertainment
Media & Entertainment Platforms: Cisco Eos
Virtual worlds: Second Life, The Sims Online, Forterra
Game sharing: Miniclip, Kongregate
Other
Information aggregators: Netvibes, Twine (website)
After looking at this list, developing a social media strategy could be confusing and seem like an enormous task.
What I think everyone who is considering SM should do at the start is set some goals and objectives for what they want to get out of social media. I am often amazed at what I consider limited thinking when it comes to social media. I am stunned when I see comments that the bottom line is for SM to generate sales and SM is poor at that. I do agree that generating sales is a goal of every business out there. My question to people who make comments like that, is PR not then justified or research or corporate responsibility projects, and other business and marketing activities that don’t directly generate sales?
I see SM in the same basket as these and it can be used for PR, research, CRM, building databases, competitions and direct marketing to name some. Is SM not a great way to communicate and engage with your customers/clients or potential customers/clients in a really fast way.
When I see people ask what’s its ROI, my answer would be that it depends on their goals and objectives and how they measure ROI. In my experience of business most companies have their own measurements for ROI and they often differ from the next. Perhaps the reason some are not to considering SM (or objecting) is that it is easier to look the other way or find reasons not to consider SM when their time and budget is already stretched. I agree that some social mediums will disappear and some will stay, social media will probably evolve, but I do believe it is here to stay. Can you afford to miss the bus (or at least keep up to date with what is going on)?
I have read a number of articles on social media and often find them thin with usable information. I am not going to call myself an expert, by my standards not many people fall into that category in many things in life. What I am going to do is go on a journey in search of case studies of successes and investigate the different channels of social media and the different practices within it e.g. SM Optimization. I hope to uncover how the different mediums could be used and how they can be measured. I will add my knowledge, experiences and thoughts to this. I know this is a big undertaking and would value everyone’s input and suggestions and even recommendations.
I will report back on each social medium that I investigate and report back in a series of articles, unfortunately I can not say how many there will be as this is a real time investigation.
For more information to hire Lee-Ann as a marketing coach, for workshops, talks, writing or any of her other services visit the services page.
Related posts:
- How to convince Management to use Social Media
- Social media ROI – reality or fantasy?
- YouTube for Business
5 Comments so far


Thanks Bill it is always nice to hear people enjoy reading my blog
Cool blog, enjoy following it greatly!
Melainie, I would love to hear how your organisation is measuring ROI for SM as this is one of the aspects of my investigation.
Adele great feed-back. I tried your link but it didn’t work
Excellent post. Thank you for sharing.
I think one of the basic problems companies are having is that the web is so broad and constantly changing and social media uses are still fairly new for many business to busy to follow it, that they don’t know what are realistic objectives to set.
In my blog, (see http://budurl.com/p5zv) I focus on how Customer satisfaction strategies are changing with social media and how some companies are doing well and some that are not.
I think the first thing a company should do with Social Media is to get educated as to what objectives are possible and then start listening to customer feedback. Then they can set some objectives.
Adele
Having worked in an organisation that manages ROI reporting successfully social media can compliment a business in terms of sales and branding, however I think you are totally right in your blog to say that there must be a clear objective before embarking on social media activity as without it there is no direction and it is an overwhelming minefield to know what is right for the business.